A hearty day of MLB action supplies us with enough fodder for a three-leg parlay.
The pregame narrative: DJ LeMahieu and Jose Abreu enter Tuesday night with strong track records against the pitcher they'll be facing, making both quality options for our parlay. The San Diego Padres, meanwhile, are a nice pick to win with ace Blake Snell taking the bump.
Find all our MLB parlay picks for Sept. 19 below.
MLB parlay picks overview
Click link to add selection to betslip. Note: Lines have changed/market no longer available if grey.
| Picks | Odds | Bet now ⬇️ |
| LeMahieu over 0.5 hits | -240 | Add to betslip |
| Abreu over 0.5 hits | -240 | Add to betslip |
| Padres moneyline | -286 | Add to betslip |
MLB odds as of 10:26 a.m. ET on 09/19/23.
Go to full MLB betting markets.
MLB parlay picks
Parlay: LeMahieu over 0.5 hits + Abreu over 0.5 hits + Padres moneyline (+172)
LeMahieu over 0.5 hits (-240): LeMahieu's best years appear to be in his rearview, but he's finishing the 2023 season on a strong note.
The New York Yankees star is batting an uninspiring .244 this year, almost a full 50 points below his career mark (.293).
Sign up now to receive NorthStar's Best Bets newsletter.
He has been much better over the second half of his campaign, though, batting a respectable .279 since the All-Star Game. LeMahieu has a hit in each of his last five games.
He battles Toronto Blue Jays starter Yusei Kikuchi and that's a matchup he's done well in. LeMahieu is 7-for-21 with a pair of doubles.
| MLB boosts Sept. 19 | Odds | Bet now ⬇️ |
| Blue Jays ML & over 9.5 runs | +350 (was +320) | Add to betslip |
| Kikuchi to record 8+ strikeouts | +385 (was +350) | Add to betslip |
| Strider & Snell to combine for 20+ strikeouts | +290 (was +265) | Add to betslip |
| Mariners, Padres & Dodgers to all win by 2+ runs | +550 (was +500) | Add to betslip |
Other parlay picks
Abreu over 0.5 hits (-240): Abreu finds himself in a similar position as LeMahieu.
The first baseman is having a down season, batting .235 versus a career mark of .287. He has put up better numbers as of late, however, posting a .270 average across his last 10 outings.
Abreu has been very successful against the pitcher he'll see on Tuesday, Baltimore Orioles starter Kyle Gibson. He's 11-for-40 with a pair of doubles and four long balls against the righty.
Gibson isn't having a great year, either, pairing a 4.98 ERA with a 4.13 FIP. He's been even worse as of late, earning a 6.38 ERA and a 5.27 FIP in seven starts since the beginning of August.
Padres moneyline (-286): Thirdly, we're backing the NL Cy Young favourite to help San Diego beat the lowly Colorado Rockies.
Snell pairs a sterling 2.43 ERA with a solid 3.53 FIP, ranking first in MLB in the former. His numbers since the beginning of June are otherworldly as he owns a 1.38 ERA and 2.77 FIP in 19 appearances and his team is 14-5 during this stretch.
Lefties have mystified the Rockies this year as they have the second-worst OPS in MLB (.678) against southpaws.
Colorado counters with Ryan Feltner and he's not being confused with an NL Cy Young contender. He carries a 5.86 ERA and 4.33 FIP into Tuesday's contest and has allowed four earned runs in each of his last two outings.
Looking to get started? Sign up here.